In the days after the election, there has been a lot of great conversation in the Message Box Pro Discord, and I have heard from many of you directly via email or in person at Crooked Con and the Majority Democrats conference this week in Denver.

One question that keeps coming up is what to do after losing a campaign. Many Message Box Pro subscribers ran in incredibly red districts and came up just short despite the Blue Tsunami.

When I started Message Box Pro, these candidates and campaigns were exactly the ones I wanted to help. I believe deeply that we need to run everywhere, and the national party apparatus and the consulting business in general are not set up to help these candidates. Great organizations like Run for Something are recruiting and training them, but too many are left with little help.

By definition, even in great years, most longshot candidates will lose. When that happens, the question is what comes next.

Here are some thoughts:

1. Get Some Sleep

Whether you ran for office or worked on a campaign, you’re exhausted. I’m spent, and all I did was type and talk about these races. Take a moment to rest and recharge your batteries.

2. Be Damn Proud

The brutal reality of politics is that it’s a completely binary outcome. You win or you lose. There are no participation trophies. Losing by one vote feels the same as losing by a million votes. Either way, you don’t get to serve in the office you wanted.

But that’s not really true. Every time a good candidate runs a good campaign in a very red district, it’s a step toward flipping that district. They improve the voter list, add volunteers, and spend time, energy, and money showing that Democrats in real life don’t look like Democrats on Fox News.

That matters.

James Talarico and Gina Hinojosa won in Texas because Beto O’Rourke, Colin Allred, and others ran hard in the state. Keisha Lance Bottoms won in Georgia because of Stacey Abrams’s work in her two runs for governor. Scott Colom won because people like Mike Espy and Brandon Presley ran hard and lost.

I don’t mean to sugarcoat it. Losing sucks. Change doesn’t happen overnight, but we are closer because you made the brave decision to run for office or work for someone who did.

3. Thank Your Supporters, Donors, and Volunteers

I have no doubt that you all did this, but too many campaigns just shut down as soon as the race is called. Everyone checks out, and no one talks to the people who poured their sweat, time, and money into the race.

A personal letter, or even a post-campaign party or reception, can go a long way toward helping people feel good about their effort despite the loss.

4. Find Out What Happened

It’s well worth the time to do a post-campaign analysis: what you did right and where you came up short. Some answers won’t be available until the voter file updates in a few months. Work with the state party to make sure you have access, or that they pull the numbers, so you know who voted and who didn’t.

Some questions I would ask:

  • What was Democratic turnout in your district, and how did it compare to previous years and neighboring districts?

  • Were you outspent, and if so, by how much?

  • How did your opponent spend their money? Did they do things you didn’t do? Should you have done those things?

  • Once you have the voter file, match it to your voter contact list and see how many turned out. Did you contact enough voters? Did you contact the right voters?

It’s also worth talking to lots of people. Start with community leaders and stakeholders, but I would also reach out to some voters to see how they viewed the campaign and why they voted the way they did.

5. Do You Want to Run Again?

I hope the answer is yes, but you don’t have to answer this question right now. There’s plenty of time to think it over.

As you do, I would offer these prompts:

  • Did you like running? Was it a passion project, or did you dread every forum, fair, and fundraiser?

  • Does the data suggest that another run would have a better chance of success? Remember, if the plan is to run in 2028, that will be a presidential year with turnout that could be 40% higher than last Tuesday. That will mean different things in different districts, but it’s an important factor to consider.

  • What would you do differently?

  • If you were outspent, is there a way to raise enough money to be competitive?

If you do decide to run, you don’t have to start right away. People need a break. But it’s worth thinking through how you stay in the public eye and in touch with the people who matter over the coming months.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate